Regional Vitalization: Japan at the Crossroads

facebooktwittergoogle_pluslinkedintumblrmail

The Heisei mergers are long done and Japan has turned to vitalizing its rural economy. The question is whether such a policy will work.

Memo #331

By Anthony Rausch – asrausch [at] cc.hirosaki-u.ac.jp

Andrew S. RauschThe current focus on regional vitalization by the Abe Cabinet reflects Japanese concern with its dropping rural population and Tokyo-centered economy. The question facing Japan is whether the policy that has been crafted to achieve vitalization is simply a repeat of the municipal mergers of a decade ago.

The Heisei mergers, the municipal mergers of the Heisei era (1989~), undertaken from 2000 to 2006, represented a neo-liberal response to the perceived fiscal ineffectiveness of Japan’s developmental state economy. Pre-mergers, the central government subsidized over 3,000 local economies through massive infrastructural development funded by tax reallocations. The Heisei mergers program rewarded municipalities—cities, towns and villages—that merged, bringing the number down to 1,700. Ten years on, while the aims of budget streamlining and reduction have been attained, the mergers have also yielded local service inequalities and loss of security for many local residents, as it is now clear that advantaged municipalities attracted partners and prosper (which they would have regardless), while disadvantaged municipalities, even those that merged, still struggle.

The Abe Cabinet is now adopting a similar approach to regional revitalization, calling on municipalities to outline a “strategic vitalization plan” to cultivate local industry through small-scale enterprises, capitalize on local “originality,” and to ensure sufficient residents. However, the reality for local places is much more complex, if not problematic. Rural places often need “vitalization” precisely because they are rural places; a lack of economic dynamism—innovative industry, for example—is inescapable and the options of vitalization strategies are few.

Regional vitalization as national policy will likely ultimately yield the same result as the Heisei mergers. The lesson that should have been learned from the mergers is that perhaps the best that can be negotiated for many rural areas is “managed continuity,” where the trajectory of a disadvantaged locale is managed, with national-level support, so as to minimize the inequality in service for locals and image for tourism vis a vis more advantaged places. As more and more urbanites recognize the “lifestyle value” of non-urban locales, long-term regional vitalization may best be envisioned as ensuring that regional areas simply survive.

Anthony S. Rausch is a professor at Hirosaki University, Japan.

If you enjoyed this memo, subscribe to our e-newsletter for free and receive new memos weekly via email.

Figure showing decline from 3.232 municipalities as of March 31, 1999 to 1,727 as of March 31, 2010 (Source: http://www.soumu.go.jp/english/lab/).

Figure showing decline from 3.232 municipalities as of March 31, 1999 to 1,727 as of March 31, 2010 (Source: http://www.soumu.go.jp/english/lab/).

 

Links:

Related Memos:

See our other memos on Japan.

 

Asia Pacific Memo AAS ad_2014.10

Print Friendly

Japan’s Economy & Trade (A Video Interview with Watanabe Yorizumi)

Memo #280

Featuring Watanabe Yorizumi

Last month the Asia Pacific Memo sat down with Watanabe Yorizumi, since 2005 a member of the Faculty of Policy Management at the Graduate School of Media and Governance, Keio University. Professor Watanabe came to his academic career with a distinguished diplomatic background, having served several appointments in Japan’s foreign service, where he specialized in international trade policy. His diplomatic career saw significant engagement… Continue reading

Reforming “Regular” Employment in Japan: A Target of Abenomics’ “Third Arrow”

Memo #273

By Scott North – north [at] hus.osaka-u.ac.jp

“Regular” employment in Japan connotes unlimited samurai-style devotion by employees, with employers responsible for worker well-being and employment stability. Japan’s courts cite this relationship ideal to restrict employers’ legal right to dismiss workers. Therefore, to cut costs, employers have turned to increasing non-regular employees, which now comprise some 40%… Continue reading

Resolving the Senkaku/Diaoyu Island Dispute: The Limitations of International Law

Pacific Prospective features the research of graduate students.

Memo #272

By  Keshav Kelkar – keshav.kelkar [at] alumni.ubc.ca

Among the many issues causing friction in Sino-Japanese relations, none has as great a potential for generating armed conflict as the dispute over the Senkaku, or Diaoyu Islands. And in attempts to resolve the impasse, international law has if… Continue reading

The Global Intensification of Supplementary Education

Memo #271

Featuring Julian Dierkes

Recently, Ee-Seul Yoon of the Faculty of Education at UBC in coordination with the Asia Pacific Memo sat down with Dr. Julian Dierkes, Associate Professor and Keidanren Chair in Japanese Research at UBC’s Institute for Asian Research, to pose a few questions about Professor Dierkes’ recently co-edited volume, Out of the Shadows: The Global Intensification Of Supplementary Education, which was published in December 2013… Continue reading

Against Abe: Listening for Oppositional Voices within Japan

Memo #268

By Hyung-Gu Lynn – hlynn [at] mail.ubc.ca

The poster beside the headquarters of the ruling Liberal Democratic Party (LDP) in Tokyo features a photograph of Prime Minister Abe Shinzō, adorned with the slogan “Take back Japan!” Most English-language media accounts and op-eds create the impression that all of Japan is enthusiastic in its endorsement of… Continue reading

Fragmentation vs. Integration in Asia in 2014: A Year for the History Books

Memo #259

By Yves Tiberghien – yves.tiberghien [at] ubc.ca

Dr. Tiberghien at the G-20 in St. Petersburg, Russia (September 2013).

In the wake of major leadership change around East Asia, what will be the major trends in the Asia/Pacific region in 2014? Did the battle over the Chinese Air Defense Identification Zone… Continue reading

Japan-China Relations: Issues and Prospects (Video Interview with Akio Takahara) – Part 2 of 2

Memo #254

Featuring Akio Takahara

In part two of his interview with the Asia Pacific Memo (see part one here), Dr. Akio Takahara , a professor in the Graduate School of Law and Politics at the University of Tokyo and a recognized authority on contemporary Chinese politics and Japan-China relations, talks about bridging the divides in Japan-China relations. Dr. Takahara contrasts the “resilient” versus the “fragile” aspects of… Continue reading

Japan-China Relations: Issues and Prospects (Video Interview with Akio Takahara) – Part 1 of 2

Memo #253

Featuring Akio Takahara

Recently the Asia Pacific Memo sat down with Dr. Akio Takahara, Professor in the Graduate School of Law and Politics at the University of Tokyo and a recognized authority on contemporary Chinese politics, international relations in East Asia, and Japan-China relations in particular.

In this first part of a two-part video memo, Dr… Continue reading

Japan as Test Case for a New Age: The Importance of Understanding Local Places

Memo #240

By Anthony S. Rausch – asrausch [at] cc.hirosaki-u.ac.jp

Japan faces an aging population and rural out-migration, a sluggish economy and drastic divisions between urban-rural economies, a critical techno-environmental catastrophe and vital debates regarding energy policy. A bleak set of problems, but also a fair representation of some of the issues the… Continue reading